← Back to blog

Richmond Historic Masonry Permits: What Needs Approval

November 19, 2026
Richmond Historic Masonry Permits: What Needs Approval

If your brick home or building sits in one of Richmond's City Old and Historic Districts, masonry work can involve two separate approvals: a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) from the city's preservation board, and a building permit. In-kind repair of existing materials, such as replacing failed mortar with a matching mix, generally does not need a COA application, but changes visible from the street often do. As a Richmond masonry family with over 25 years in the trade, we explain below how to tell which approvals your project needs, and how matching your brick and lime mortar keeps the project simple.

Heritage Masonry & Brick
Plan Brick Repairs With Care
Heritage Masonry & Brick repairs Richmond brickwork, matching existing brick and mortar with traditional methods suited to historic buildings.
Visit

TL;DR

  • A COA is required for exterior changes visible from a public right of way in a City Old and Historic District. In-kind repair of existing materials does not require a COA application.
  • A building permit is applied for separately. If it includes an item that needs a COA, the city withholds the permit until the Commission of Architectural Review approves.
  • Administrative approvals for small, in-kind repairs generally take 1 to 3 days. A full COA process usually takes 30 to 60 days.
  • National Register or Virginia Landmarks Register listing alone does not trigger historic review. Local district designation does.
  • Matching the original brick and lime mortar is both good preservation practice and the easiest way to stay within the city's guidelines.

Table of Contents

Who reviews masonry work in Richmond

The Commission of Architectural Review (CAR) is Richmond's official historic preservation body. City Council established it in 1957, and it reviews exterior changes to structures within the city's Old and Historic Districts. When a project is appropriate, the CAR issues a COA.

A COA is a different thing from a building permit. The COA answers the question "is this change appropriate for the historic district?" The building permit answers "does this work meet the building code?" On a historic property you may need one, the other, or both.

For Richmond homeowners the districts that matter most for brick are the ones many of our customers live in: the Fan, the Museum District, Monument Avenue and the neighborhoods around them. If you are not sure your address is inside a City Old and Historic District, the city's preservation staff can tell you before you spend anything.

Local historic district or National Register: why it matters

Many owners assume that a plaque or a National Register listing means a review board must approve their brick work. It does not. Richmond's Historic Preservation page explains that the City Old and Historic District designation is a zoning overlay administered by the CAR, while listing on the National Register of Historic Places and the Virginia Landmarks Register is largely honorific. Owners of properties that are only listed are not subject to historic review requirements.

The Virginia Department of Historic Resources says the same thing from the state side: locally designated historic districts are the only ones in Virginia that can include architectural review, while National Register and Virginia Landmarks Register designations do not regulate private property owners.

The practical test is simple. Ask whether your address is in a City Old and Historic District. If it is, the rules below apply. If it is only listed nationally or at the state level, the CAR process does not apply, though ordinary building permit rules still do.

Local historic district or National Register: why it matters

Which masonry work needs a COA, a permit, or both

The city's CAR submission requirements set out the dividing line: changes not visible from a public right of way, and in-kind repair of existing materials, do not require a COA application. The city's residential building plan requirements add that a COA is required for exterior alterations visible from the public right of way in a City Old and Historic District before a building permit is issued.

Here is how that plays out for common brick jobs in a historic district:

ProjectLikely approval path
Repointing with matching mortar, same joint profileIn-kind repair; confirm with preservation staff, often handled administratively
Replacing a few failed bricks with matching brickIn-kind repair; confirm with staff
Rebuilding a street-facing chimney with different brick or a new designLikely COA, and possibly a building permit
New brick steps or a walkway visible from the streetLikely COA; building permit questions depend on the work
Changing the look of a brick facade, such as new openings or different materialsCOA, then building permit
Painting unpainted brickNot permitted, according to the city's 2024 Homeowner's Guide

This table is a planning guide, not a ruling. The city applies its guidelines case by case, and its Old and Historic District Handbook uses words such as "should," "must," "may," "encouraged" and "discouraged" to signal how binding each guideline is. A call to staff before you start settles the question for your specific house.

The "small repairs are exempt" misconception

Ordinary repairs are often exempt from a building permit, so owners assume repointing in a historic district is exempt as well. The city's residential requirements note that alterations normally exempt from a permit may still require one in a historic district, under Virginia Residential Code Section 108.2 and Code of Virginia Section 15.2-2306. A Richmond real estate practitioner makes the same point about repointing: the ordinary repair exemption does not automatically carry over to exterior work in a City Old and Historic District.

The safe habit is to phone the Planning and Development Review staff at (804) 646-6335 before work starts. The city's guidelines recommend exactly that, ahead of filling out any COA form.

Painting brick

The city's 2024 Homeowner's Guide states that unpainted masonry is not permitted to be painted. Painting that is administratively approved is possible for other surfaces, and no approval is needed to paint the same color or touch up existing paint. If your brick was never painted, treat it as bare brick for good.

How the permit and the COA fit together

The sequence matters more than most owners expect. Per the city's submission requirements, a building permit may be filed at the same time as a COA application. But approval of a permit that includes an item requiring a COA is withheld until the Commission approves it. If the Commission attaches conditions, the permit documents must be amended to reflect them.

The city also warns that revisions to approved work require staff review and may require a new application and Commission approval. Failing to comply with COA conditions may result in project delays or legal action, according to the COA application form. In practice that means the brick you describe on the application is the brick that goes on the wall.

What a COA application needs for brick work

A complete application includes a signed form (the property owner must sign), the checklist, legible plans, drawings, elevations and material specifications, plus the fee under City Code Sec. 30-930.6(b). The April 2023 application form states that late or incomplete applications will not be considered.

For exterior masonry work, the CAR requirements ask you to:

  1. Document all of the work being proposed.
  2. Identify each material as repaired, a matching replacement, or new.
  3. Describe distinctly textured or colored materials such as brick, stone and concrete, or provide product literature and samples.

This is where an accurate description of your brick and mortar pays off. Vague wording such as "repair brick" invites questions. A specific description of the brick size, color and texture, the mortar type and the joint profile gives staff what they need. Our blog explains how sample panels help avoid CAR delays on Richmond historic masonry.

How to apply, how long it takes, and what it costs

Where to apply. According to the current CAR page, COA applications are accepted only through the City's Online Permit Portal. You register, click "Apply," and select the Commission of Architectural Review plan type, then also send the signed application and plans by email or OneDrive. Fees are invoiced through the portal and must be paid before the application is scheduled. Administratively approved applications and conceptual reviews are not charged a fee. Check the CAR page for the current fee schedule, since fees can change.

How long it takes. The 2024 Homeowner's Guide says the COA process usually takes 30 to 60 days. Applications should generally be submitted by the 4th Friday of the month to be heard at the following month's meeting. Smaller projects such as in-kind replacement and repair can often be approved administratively in generally 1 to 3 days. The CAR holds its regular meeting at City Hall, 900 E. Broad Street, and the city publishes the current meeting calendar on its CAR page.

How long the approval lasts. A COA is valid for one year and can be extended for another year with a written request and the associated fee. Schedule your masonry contractor with that window in mind.

Larger or more complex work. The city's guidelines suggest a conceptual review for larger or more complex projects, and staff recommend meeting before you submit if you are proposing major new construction or additions.

The Commission is active on masonry-adjacent work. Its May 2025 agenda included a deferred request to install a display board on the integrated masonry wall of a historic church on West Franklin Street, and a request to replace a slate roof with copper on Monument Avenue. Those are the kinds of visible exterior changes that go before the board.

Why brick and lime mortar matter to approval

The CAR has adopted the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation as its national yardstick. They call for retaining historic character, avoiding the removal of historic materials, and differentiating new work from old. For masonry, that translates into a plain idea: repair what you have, and match what you cannot save.

Mason repointing an older Richmond brick wall

That is how we work on every Richmond job. We match the existing brick and mortar so the repair blends in, and we use the traditional methods old brick was built with. Richmond's older houses, including many in the Fan and Museum District, were laid with lime mortar. Lime mortar is softer and more flexible than modern cement-based mortar, so it is designed to take the movement and moisture that a wall goes through, while the brick stays intact. Our repointing work uses traditional lime mortar for lasting repairs.

A good lime mortar repair involves more than choosing a bag of lime:

  • Mortar color and texture. Sand, lime and aggregate are matched to the original joints so the repair is not a visible patch.
  • Joint profile. The shape of the joint (flush, concave, struck) is part of the building's character and is reproduced, not replaced with a generic finish.
  • Brick matching. Historic Richmond brick varies in size, color and surface. Replacement units are chosen to sit alongside the old ones.
  • Depth of work. Deteriorated mortar is carefully removed to a proper depth before new mortar is placed.

To see how repointing is done, our pages on brick repointing and masonry restoration methods for historic brick in Richmond go step by step. Our guide to repointing costs in Richmond explains why mortar match matters.

Brick is also part of how a house looks after dark. If you are planning exterior lighting on a brick facade, these brick house lighting ideas show how different fixtures work with brick surfaces.

Steps, walkways, chimneys and foundations

The approval question changes with the part of the house. As a rule of thumb for planning:

  • Front steps and street-facing walkways. These are highly visible, so expect staff to look at brick type, bond pattern and mortar. Repairing existing steps in kind is the simplest route. New steps are a change and are more likely to need a COA.
  • Chimneys. A chimney rebuild that reproduces the original brick and corbelling is a repair. A redesign is a change. A chimney is also a structural and safety element, so the building permit side deserves attention.
  • Rear patios and walls. Work not visible from a public right of way does not require a COA application, per the city's submission requirements, but building permit rules may still apply.
  • Foundations and retaining walls. These can involve structural work. Ask the city's staff about the specific property.

We repair and build brick steps, patios and walkways, chimneys, retaining walls and structural brick work in Richmond. Whichever you need, the first step is the same: identify the work as in-kind repair or as a change, and describe it in specific terms.

When the repair cannot wait

Sometimes water is getting in, joints are crumbling, a step is loose or a wall is cracking, and waiting 30 to 60 days is not comfortable. Start by calling the city's preservation staff at (804) 646-6335 to ask whether your repair can be approved administratively, since the city says in-kind repair can be handled in generally 1 to 3 days. If anything looks like it could fall, keep people away from it, and call 911 if someone is in immediate danger. Then call us for an estimate so the cause of the damage is identified and a matching repair can be scoped.

Our article on when to repoint brick lays out how to judge urgency.

Property managers, agents and builders

The same rules apply to commercial brick and investment properties inside City Old and Historic Districts. Property managers should treat every visible exterior brick repair as a question for preservation staff before the contractor starts. Real estate agents can tell sellers that approved, well-documented, matching repairs help a property show well. Builders who design new brick features in a district should plan for conceptual review and a COA ahead of the building permit, since the permit waits on the COA.

Heritage Masonry & Brick in Richmond

We are a family run masonry company in Richmond, Virginia, specializing in historic brick restoration. Our work covers lime mortar repointing and tuckpointing, brick repair, structural repairs, chimneys, steps, patios, walkways and retaining walls. We offer free estimates and a 5-year guarantee on materials and workmanship. We take no deposit, and you pay on completion.

Heritage Masonry & Brick

If you own a historic brick property in the Fan, the Museum District, along Monument Avenue or elsewhere in Richmond, call 804-324-6304 or visit our Fan and Museum District page to start with a free estimate.

Our view on historic masonry in Richmond

Richmond's brick is part of what makes its neighborhoods what they are. When a repair is done with matching brick and lime mortar, it protects the wall and the streetscape together.

The approval process is not an obstacle to good masonry. It rewards exactly what we already do: describing materials precisely, matching what is there, and repairing instead of replacing. A wall repaired in kind, with mortar made to suit the old brick, can last for decades.

Our advice to owners is to decide early what is repair and what is change, to call preservation staff before the first joint is cut, and to hire a mason who works with traditional methods every day.

Thomas

FAQ

Do I need a permit to repoint brick in a Richmond historic district?

In-kind repair of existing materials does not require a COA application, but the ordinary repair exemption from building permits does not automatically apply in a City Old and Historic District. Call Planning and Development Review staff at (804) 646-6335 before work begins to confirm what your project needs.

Does National Register listing mean I need CAR approval?

No. Richmond says National Register and Virginia Landmarks Register listing is largely honorific, and owners of those listed properties are not subject to historic review. Review applies in City Old and Historic Districts.

How long does a Certificate of Appropriateness take?

The city's 2024 Homeowner's Guide says the process usually takes 30 to 60 days, with applications generally due by the 4th Friday of the month for the following month's meeting. Smaller in-kind repairs can be administratively approved in generally 1 to 3 days.

Can I paint my brick in a Richmond historic district?

The city's guide states that unpainted masonry is not permitted to be painted. You can paint the same color or touch up existing paint without approval.

Where do I submit a COA application?

COA applications are accepted through the City's Online Permit Portal, where you choose the Commission of Architectural Review plan type. Fees are invoiced through the portal and must be paid before the application is scheduled.

Heritage Masonry & Brick
Discuss Your Historic Brickwork
Contact Heritage Masonry & Brick to discuss brick repairs, lime mortar repointing, chimneys, or other masonry work on your Richmond property.

Sources